Windrow vs Trough Composting: Choosing a Turner

Compare windrow, trough and enclosed-tank composting for manure, with typical dimensions and the Renyuan turner and tank models for each method.

Compost turner working inside a composting hall

Three ways to compost manure

WindrowTroughEnclosed tank
How it worksLong piles on open ground or under a roof; a crawler turner straddles and turns each pileMaterial sits in walled troughs; a turner runs along the walls and moves between troughs on a transfer trolleyMaterial is composted with forced aeration inside a closed tank
Typical sizePiles 2–3 m wide, 1–1.5 m highTroughs 3–20 m wide, 0.8–1.5 m deep, 50–100 m longChamber 32–116 m³ (Renyuan range)
Composting timeAbout 10–15 days with inoculant and regular turningAbout 15 days in summer, 25 in winterComposting is completed inside the tank
StrengthsLow civil work; flexible pile layoutStandardised production; not affected by weather or season; low pollutionNo odour release; handles manure up to about 80% moisture
Watch forNeeds a large yard; weather affects open sitesTrough construction; moisture above 65% risks a failed startBatch volume is limited by chamber size

Windrow turners

A crawler turner suits sites with yard space and gives the most flexible layout. Choose the turning width to match the windrow cross-section you plan.

ModelTurning widthReference capacityPower
RY-LFD2500 – RY-LFD35002.5–3.5 m577.5–1029 m³/hup to 132 kW
RY-YFD3500 / RY-YFD40003.5 / 4.0 m1250 / 1596 m³/h160 / 194 kW
RY-YFD50005.0 m2205 m³/h247 kW
RY-YFD60006.0 m2574 m³/h306 kW
RY-YLD60006.0 m2772 m³/h315 kW

Trough turners

Trough turners suit plants that want steady, year-round output. The trough width and depth fix the turner model.

ModelTurning widthTurning depthReference capacity
RY-ZFP-40A / 50A3.76 / 4.76 m≤1.0 m225.6 / 285.6 m³/h
RY-ZFP-40B / 50B3.76 / 4.76 m≤1.5 m338.4 / 428.4 m³/h
RY-ZFP-40AY – 50BY (hydraulic)3.74–4.74 m≤1.1–1.5 m246.84–426.6 m³/h

The RY-YLF impeller turner also mixes, cools and aerates material in troughs, with working height adjustable to the material depth.

Composting controls that apply to every method

  • Particle size under 10 mm.
  • Moisture around 55–60% for troughs; above 65% risks a failed start.
  • Bulking material with a C:N ratio of 20–80:1, typically at a manure-to-bulking ratio of about 3:1.
  • Turn once the pile has held 60–70 °C for 24 hours.

How to decide

  • Plenty of yard space and a lower civil budget: windrows with a crawler turner.
  • Limited space, wet seasons or a need for standardised output: troughs with a trough turner.
  • Strict odour limits or small daily volumes: an enclosed fermentation tank.

Renyuan equipment for this line

  • RY-LFD Series Crawler Compost Turner

    RY-LFD crawler turners mix and aerate composting windrows across several working widths. Start with windrow width, then check site access and the turning requirements of the selected model.

  • Fully Hydraulic Crawler Compost Turner

    The fully hydraulic RY-YFD4000 and RY-YFD3500 turn organic materials in ground-level windrows. The two widths allow the model to be matched to the composting layout and windrow size.

  • RY-YFD5000 Semi-Hydraulic Crawler Compost Turner

    RY-YFD5000 turns and mixes manure, straw and other organic materials in open windrows for aerobic composting. Its semi-hydraulic crawler arrangement includes a split-frame lifting design; check both windrow dimensions and transfer space.

  • RY-YFD6000 Fully Hydraulic Crawler Compost Turner

    RY-YFD6000 is a fully hydraulic crawler turner with a 6,000 mm turning width. It turns, mixes and aerates organic material in open windrows. Check pile cross-section, spacing between windrows and turning radius together.

  • RY-ZFP Standard Trough Compost Turner

    The standard RY-ZFP series turns and mixes organic material in fixed composting troughs. The 40/50 and A/B combinations have different widths, working depths and main motor ratings, so selection begins with the trough geometry.

  • RY-ZFP Hydraulic Trough Compost Turner

    A hydraulic-drive trough turner listed with four RY-ZFP models and model-specific dimensions and motor data.

  • RY-YLF Impeller Compost Turner

    An impeller turner for mixing, cooling and aerating material during organic-waste fermentation.

  • Intelligent Aerobic Fermentation Tank

    The aerobic fermentation tank combines a chamber, lifting feed system, aeration, hydraulics and biological odor treatment for manure and other organic materials. Compare chamber volume and the stated treatment quantity separately across the four sizes.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, windrow or trough composting?

Neither is better in general. Windrows need more yard space but less construction. Troughs give steadier output and are not affected by season. Choose by site, climate and odour requirements.

How wide should a composting trough be?

Typically 3–20 m wide and 0.8–1.5 m deep, depending on the turner. RY-ZFP trough turners work 3.74–4.76 m widths at depths up to 1.5 m.

Process guide
Call salesEmailDiscuss selection

WhatsApp

Scan the QR code to add our WhatsApp contact and share feedstock, product and site details for equipment and project configuration.

Wendy Mathew

WhatsApp contact QR code
Open in WhatsApp

Project pack

Keep selected equipment and models together for technical and purchasing review. Check the final configuration in the supply proposal.